The Feed
Fresh insights, smart solutions, and the science behind them
Methane emissions from livestock are a major contributor to greenhouse gases, making sustainable animal nutrition a crucial area of research
I am Enrico Colella, an Italian exchange student from Wageningen University, and during my exchange semester at ETH Zurich, I had the opportunity to contribute to this field through the “Training Course in Group: Large,” working alongside Professor Mutian Niu and PhD student Kai Wang in the Animal Nutrition Research Group.
The project focused on exploring dietary strategies to reduce methane emissions in dairy cows, specifically investigating the potential synergy between 3-NOP, a commercially available methane inhibitor known as Bovaer, and whey powder. While 3-NOP had already been proven effective in lowering methane production, our study aimed to assess whether combining it with whey powder enhanced its effect through interactions with rumen microbiota, particularly lactic acid bacteria.
Research at ETH Zurich
The experiment took place at the research facility AgroVet-Strickhof, a collaboration between ETH Zurich, University of Zurich and Strickhof.
Using a 2x2 factorial design, 24 cows were assigned to four different treatment groups: placebo, Bovaer, placebo + whey, and Bovaer + whey. Over a 12-week period, various samples were collected and analyzed, including rumen fluid for microbiome studies, fecal samples to assess digestibility, and milk samples to evaluate production efficiency and methane intensity.
My role in the research involved hands-on work essential to the study’s execution. I collected various samples such as milk, feed, and rumen fluid, along with performing practical tasks such as feeding and milking cows. The collection of samples was followed by physical processes including grinding, drying, and weighing. Afterwards, data was analyzed. I also managed GreenFed functions (a turn-key system designed to measure gas fluxes of methane (CH4), carbon dioxide (CO2), and optionally, oxygen (O2), and hydrogen (H2) from individual animals), transcribed experimental data, assisted in laboratory procedures, and oversaw fecal schedule processes.
Through this, I gained direct experience in livestock research methodologies.
Beyond the technical work, this experience provided a valuable perspective on the inner workings of academic research. I saw firsthand how interdisciplinary collaboration, experimental design, and data collection functioned in practice.
Although my participation concluded at the end of the data collection phase, the study continued under Kai Wang’s supervision, with ongoing analysis to determine the effectiveness of the whey powder and Bovaer combination.
Moreover, by being fully immersed in the Animal Nutrition Group and participating in weekly group meetings, I gained a deeper understanding of how research was conducted, who was involved, and how supervision worked. I learned about the different hierarchies in a scientific group, the role of the professor, and how they managed experiments, finances, and a team composed of PhD students and postdoctoral scientists.
This training course provided a unique and enriching opportunity to delve deeper into animal nutrition research while contributing to a broader discussion on agricultural sustainability. My time at ETH Zurich reinforced the importance of innovative solutions in addressing environmental challenges in livestock farming. By sharing this experience, I hope to inspire other students to engage in sustainability-focused scientific research.
21.03.2025
Are Food Firms’ Efforts to Reduce Cow Methane Emissions Effective? An Interview with Mutian Niu
Methane emissions from cattle, a major contributor to climate change, have drawn increasing attention from multinational food companies. In a recent SWI swissinfo.ch article, Mutian Niu, professor of animal nutrition at ETH Zurich, shares expert insights on the role of feed additives in tackling this issue.
Mutian Niu: The Science Behind Feed Additives
Niu explains that methane from cows is primarily produced by microbes in their digestive system, particularly in the rumen. Scientists have been exploring ways to modify this microbial activity through feed additives, which can either inhibit key enzymes in methane production or alter gut conditions to suppress methanogenesis.
One of the most researched additives is 3-NOP (3-nitrooxypropanol), which has demonstrated a methane reduction potential of up to 30% in controlled trials. Other natural solutions, such as plant extracts and seaweed-based supplements, are also being tested. However, Niu emphasizes that the long-term effectiveness of these solutions depends on factors like diet composition, animal health, and farm management practices.
Beyond methane reduction, Niu highlights that some feed additives could increase milk production efficiency by redirecting energy that would otherwise be lost as methane. This dual benefit has made them an attractive option for both researchers and the dairy industry. However, Niu cautions that real-world results can vary, and more large-scale studies are needed to assess their impact across different farming systems.
Industry Efforts and Challenges
Food giants are promoting feed-based methane reduction as part of their sustainability strategies. Swiss farmers, for instance, have tested plant-based additives, achieving a 10-20% reduction in methane emissions. However, experts note that practical experience with these additives remains limited, and their effectiveness outside controlled studies is still uncertain.
The Road Ahead
While companies push forward with methane-reducing solutions, experts like Niu stress the need for long-term trials and policy support to ensure these methods are viable, cost-effective, and widely adopted.
👉 Read the full article on SWI swissinfo.ch to explore the full scope of the discussion. (external page Read More)
05.03.2025 (article created with the support of AI)